Skip to content

The Smith Manoeuvre

The Smith Manoeuvre is a Canadian strategy for gradually turning non-deductible mortgage debt into tax-deductible investment debt. Each time a mortgage payment reduces your principal, you re-borrow that amount from a linked line of credit and invest it. Because the money is borrowed to earn investment income, the interest on it can be tax-deductible.

Book a consultation

How it works, step by step

  1. Set up a readvanceable mortgage. A mortgage and a HELOC under one registration. As the mortgage balance goes down, HELOC room goes up by the same amount.
  2. Make your regular mortgage payment. Part of it reduces your principal.
  3. Re-borrow the principal you just paid. Draw that amount from the HELOC.
  4. Invest it in a non-registered account, in investments expected to produce income, chosen with a licensed investment professional.
  5. Deduct the HELOC interest on your tax return, and put the tax refund (and any investment income) toward the mortgage. That frees more HELOC room, and the cycle speeds up.

An example

Say your mortgage payment includes $1,000 of principal this month. Your mortgage drops by $1,000, your HELOC limit rises by $1,000, and you borrow that $1,000 to invest. Your total debt is unchanged, but $1,000 of it is now investment debt with interest that may be deductible. Repeat every month and, over the years, more of your debt becomes deductible while an investment portfolio builds alongside it.

Benefits and risks

Potential benefitsRisks and costs
Interest on the investment portion may be tax-deductibleInvestments can fall while the debt stays the same
Builds a non-registered portfolio while you pay your mortgageHELOC rates are variable, so rising rates raise your costs
Tax refunds can accelerate paying off the non-deductible mortgageYour total debt doesn’t fall; it changes type
Can be combined with cash damming for rental ownersMixing personal spending into the investment HELOC can spoil the tax deduction; careful records are essential

Who it can suit

  • Homeowners with stable income and solid home equity
  • People with a long investment horizon who are comfortable with market ups and downs
  • People who will keep separate accounts and records, every year

It’s usually not a fit if your income is uncertain, you’d need the money in the next few years, or a market drop would cause you real stress.

How we help

We find and arrange the right readvanceable mortgage through Real Mortgage Associates, structure the HELOC segments so the investment borrowing stays separate, and make sure you have life insurance that protects your family if you’re carrying more debt for longer. Your accountant and investment professional handle the tax and investment pieces.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Smith Manoeuvre legal?

Yes. It relies on a long-standing rule: interest on money borrowed to earn income from a business or property can be tax-deductible. What matters is using the borrowed money correctly and being able to trace it, so get advice from an accountant before you start.

What kind of mortgage do I need?

A readvanceable mortgage, which combines a mortgage with a home equity line of credit (HELOC). As you pay down the mortgage, the credit available on the HELOC grows. Federally regulated lenders cap the revolving HELOC portion at 65% of your home’s value, and the combined total at 80%.

Can I invest the borrowed money in my RRSP or TFSA?

Interest on money borrowed to contribute to an RRSP or TFSA isn’t deductible. The strategy uses a non-registered investment account, and the investments generally need a reasonable expectation of income, such as dividends or interest.

What happens if my investments drop?

You still owe the full HELOC balance. A market drop can leave you with more debt than investments for a while. That’s the core risk, and the reason this suits people with a long time horizon, stable income and a tolerance for ups and downs.

Does it reduce my total debt?

Not by itself. You convert non-deductible mortgage debt into deductible investment debt over time; the total stays roughly the same while you build an investment portfolio alongside it.

Sources

Program rules and limits change. Figures were checked on the review date below; confirm current details with the source before relying on them.

Written by Kyle Hibbert, Managing Director, Mortgage Agent Level 2 and licensed life and health insurance agent.
Last reviewed

Talk it through before you decide

Book a free consultation. We look at where you are, explain your options in plain language, and you decide what happens next.

Book a consultation